I believe in second chances (or third or fourth or ...), but I am not an active participant of the CCGR MC-server, so I am not in a position to suggest a course of action. I'm sure Cheryl and/or mods will line out a response here soon.
What I would hope, is that you guys could find enjoyment in the creation, not annoyance, with others. Even if the ban was not lifted, and you decided to come play on the CCGR servers on alternative accounts, I would hope you guys would do it just to enjoy the company. I understand the thrill there can be involved in annoying others, but I would suggest thinking about the long run: I know from experience, that you can even make life-long friends on the internet, learn and shares things just like in real-life relationships. Sure, it may feel cool to harrass a community of Christians over the internet, but you might just gain so much more from living peacefully along-side them.
And making friends applies for any server for Minecraft, not just the one offered here. Games are just games, I admit that, but the people behind the nicknames are real. Admins can rollback griefing in a blink of an eye, but friendships or even single cherished moments may last a life-time.
Gud välsigne dig!
You can find me from the CCGR Steam-group, feel free to add me as a friend!